WikiSummary, the Social Science Summary Database

Kavka: Hobbesian moral and political theory

From WikiSummary, the Free Social Science Summary Database

 
This summary needs formatting (i.e. "wikification"). Can you help us improve it? (Formatting help.) Please volunteer.

Kavka. 1986. Hobbesian moral and political theory (pages 96-125). Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Hobbes's three premises:

  1. the individually rational decision by each actor leads to a "war of all against all"
  2. state of nature is a prisoner's dilemma leading to anarchy and misery
  3. a central political authority (leviathan) must emerge to limit aggression and bring peace, wealth, security (#3 not discussed much here)

State of nature = "a war of all against all": captured in prisoner's dilemma

Assumptions:

  • We are death-averse
  • Concerned about reputations
  • Forward-looking
  • We have desires that conflict with others' goals
  • We have roughly equal natural endowments
  • We're egoistic (concerned about your own survival over others')
  • Rational planners
  • BUT: we vary in one respect: we're either dominators (want power for its own sake) or moderates (want power only to protect myself/my stuff)

Examines several objections/criticisms of Hobbes's model.